Times Up! Age Limits on Federal Officials

Many of my friends, both Republicans and Democrats, favor term limits.  I disagree. As an 85-year-old myself, I favor age limits for presidents (and VPs), Congress and the judiciary. My adopted state of South Carolina has long had terms limits for governors and age limits for the judiciary (72, but 74 may be coming soon).  That leaves only the state legislature with no term or age limits, unwilling to limit themselves. The longest serving U.S. Senator was South Carolina’s Strom Thurmond, who retired from the Senate at age  after serving for 48 years. In his final years, we jokingly referred to the Senate as Strom’s nursing home. Until the midterms the only Democrat in Congress from South Carolina has been 897-year-old James Clyburn, just elected to his18th term.

Many of our presidents lived to a ripe old age, but most did not seek re-election to a third term until FDR. Only three people have served as President of the United States past their 75th birthday, and all three showed signs of decline during their term in office–Reagan, Biden, and Trump. Twenty percent of the 535 members  Congress (including t33 senators) over 70, and 28 of them are over 80.The federal judiciary has no mandatory retirement age. Two members of the Supreme Court are over 75 (Alito and Thomas) and two  more are fast approaching that age (Roberts and Sotomayor). We do have a term limit for presidents, which is fine, but we might be better served by setting age limits across  all three branches of the federal government . 

With age comes wisdom and experience, but also declining health, lessened mental acuity, and less familiarity with a rapidly changing world in terms of the challenges the nation faces and the choices to be  made. I know the difficulty I and my fellow old folks have in understanding and using technology, let alone regulating it.  All these officials have to make decisions about complex problems  that were not at issue when they first took their oath of office. Congress and the Presidents for both parties have a long history of paying more attention to the needs of the elderly than those of the young, perhaps because they are more familiar with the problems. They also tend to have a shorter time horizon and let problems like climate change suffer from not very benign neglect.

Take it from an octogenarian.  I still have most of my wits about me, but my vision, stamina  and memory are not what they were 10 or 20 years ago. Each of us must know when it is time to retire from the field of battle and become a wise elder who may or may not be called upon to offer the benefit of our experience. Perhaps a gentle nudging is not enough. John Kennedy was 43 when he said that “the torch has been passed to a new generation of Americans.” Time to relight that torch as we welcome younger members of the House,

Leave a Reply